Furloughs drainCalifornia economy nearly $172.3 million each month

SEIU LOCAL 1000: Focus on the Facts
Furloughs continue to drain the California economy of nearly
$172.3 million for each month they continue

Reinstating furloughs for most state employees means continued pain for an economy floundering to right itself.
The furloughs trigger a $172.3 million loss to the California economy for each month they’re in effect, $34.3
million a month for the four-county Sacramento region, home to the highest concentration of state workers.i

Though the governor’s July executive order calls for furloughs for 158,722 employeesii until the budget is passed,
the resulting economic devastation is permanent. An estimated 1,059 jobs—waiters, clerks, real estate agents—
are lost statewide for each month that furloughs are imposed. In the Sacramento region, which includes Yolo,
Placer and El Dorado counties, 302 jobs will disappear as a consequence of each month of furloughs.iii
Government also takes a hit when state workers are furloughed: cutting $125.4 million every month from state-
worker’s wallets cuts their purchasing ability, which, in turn, shrinks state and local tax revenue by $12.7 million a
month statewide and $3.5 million in the Sacramento region.

Furlough wage losses shrink the economy:

Hardest hit
The most susceptible jobs are in education and health services, those who teach recreation or computer classes,
for example, or people who work at blood banks or give speech therapy.

The association says that every $1 spent in California restaurants generates another $1.34 in the state economy and the state’s 1.4 million restaurant jobs equals 10 percent
of the California workforce.

A particularly vulnerable industry is the second hardest hit: retail and hospitality.
Reduced furlough spending surely has a forceful effect on dining: 49 cents of every
food dollar is spent in a restaurant, according to The National Restaurant

Induced Impact
$45.2 million
Indirect Impact
$43.3 million
Direct Impact
$84 million
Total California Economic Impact of $172.3 million Each
Month the Furloughs Continue
Reduction in
$100.7 million
Initial Gross
Reduction for
State Workers
$125.4 million
Enters the

This analysis uses IMPLAN Version 3 with 2007 California county and state datasets. This software is a widely respected tool,
used by the U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, U.S. Army Corp of Engineers, Federal Emergency Management Agency, California
Energy Commission, Chambers of Commerce, Deloitte & Touche, Ernst & Young, and many other public, private and
university institutions.
The Governor’s Executive Order imposing furloughs excluded employees in Bargaining Units 12, 16, 18, and 19 and eight
departments. (link to executive order)
The model assumes a constant relationship between Gross Regional Product (GRP), and the output and workforce levels for
an area. A decrease (or increase) in economic activity results in a change in workforce and output of a certain magnitude –
but the model does not account for the pace at how these actual changes occur. Thus, each month of decreased
compensation yields a predicted economic impact which may occur during the same month or may take longer to fully
manifest itself.
Though media reports cite cost savings for the state, between $145 to $150 million, that amount is actually compromised of
payroll cuts, plus additional cost savings from non-payment of OASDI/MediCare (7.65 percent of payroll) and deferred
CalPERS contributions, which will have to be repaid in a different fiscal year.
This estimate includes all fulltime state workers in civil service, except those listed in Endnote ii. Total monthly payroll
estimates are from “base pay” figures from SCO 2009 payroll data. State of California, State Controller’s Office. Civil Service
payroll data, 2009.
See Endnote i.
National Restaurant Association, “California Restaurant Industry at a Glance,” accessed Aug. 3, 2010, www.restaurant. org

Impacts by Industry for
Each Month of Furloughs*
Jobs Total Monthly
Impact (in millions)
Education and Health Services -216 -$22.2
Retail Trade -150 -$13.5
Leisure and Hospitality -152 -$10.6
Professional and Business Services -123 -$16.5
Wholesale Trade -52 -$10.1
Finance and Insurance -74 -$20.8
Real Estate and Rental and Leasing -61 -$26.6
Manufacturing -47 -$24.1
* Industries match to NAICS 2007 definitions




About Mad Scientist

Member of California Association of Professional Scientists
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s